A Quasi-Experimental Study to Assess the Effectiveness of Cognitive Behavior Therapy on Test Anxiety among Students Studying at Selected Nursing Institutes of Punjab
Ruchika Awasthi
M.Sc. Nursing, (Mental Health Nursing), Saraswati Nursing Institute Dhianpura, Roopnagar, Punjab, India.
*Corresponding Author Email: ruchikaawasthi41@gmail.com
ABSTRACT:
Background: Anxiety is our body’s natural response to stress. It is a feeling of fear or apprehension. Exam anxiety is the experience of feeling an intense moment of fear or panic before and/or during an exam or assessment. Aim: A quasi-experimental approach was used to assess the effectiveness of cognitive behavior therapy on test anxiety among students studying at selected nursing institutes of Punjab. Materials and Methods: A quasi-experimental pre-test post-test control group design was adopted to conduct the research study. Simple random sampling technique was used to select 130 BSc nursing 3rd year and 4th year students from two different institutes assigned into Experimental and Control group. Tools were used for the study socio-demographic sheet, test profile sheet, standardized tool (Test Anxiety Questionnaire by Nist and Diehl). It was found reliable (0.70). Cognitive Behavior Therapy was given once a day for 60 minutes to experimental group for 7 days regularly whereas no intervention was given to control group. Post –test was taken from on (day-8). Results: The data was analyzed by using descriptive and inferential statistics. Findings revealed that pre test scores in experimental and control group were 28±5.01 and 29.76±4.58 respectively. After intervention, posttest scored in experimental and control group was 15.29±2.44 and 29.91±4.52 respectively. The difference observed between pretest and posttest anxiety score was significant (p<0.001). Conclusion: The findings of present study suggest that cognitive behavior therapy was a valuable psychotherapy technique in reducing test anxiety among nursing students.
KEYWORDS: Cognitive Behavior Therapy, Test Anxiety, Nursing Students.
INTRODUCTION:
The environment we live in is dynamic and difficult on all levels such as physically, psychologically, emotionally, socially, and morally. We have effective mechanisms in place to deal with everyday stress. Normal adaptive mechanisms can sometimes become over-activated and, as a result, maladaptive. Anxiety is a common side effect of such over-activation. Anxiety presents itself in life endeavors in the shape of anxieties and restlessness as an emotional component of human beings. Every day, people are plagued by strong emotions as a result of life's constant challenges, which each individual seeks to solve.1
Anxiety, according to Barlow (2002), is a negative mood state marked by somatic signs of physical tension and fear of the future. It is a mental health issue with physical, emotional, cognitive, and behavioral components. Anxiety is a word for a variety of conditions that produce anxiety, insomnia, apprehension, and concern. These illnesses have an impact on how we feel and think, and they can cause physical symptoms. Mild anxiety is undefined and unsettling, however severe anxiety can be crippling and have a significant influence on daily living.2
When an individual suffers apprehension and uneasiness before during and after a specific exam, this is referred to as test anxiety. This universal human emotion has both promoting and inhibiting impacts on the learning process. While an average level of anxiety might be beneficial to kids, if they are overwhelmed by it, their performance will suffer people can profit from a reasonable level of anxiety because it motivates them to work hard and be accountable for their responsibilities, resulting in a more sustainable and prosperous life.3
NEED FOR THE STUDY:
Test anxiety is a prevalent health condition among medical students around the world. The prevalence of troublesome test anxiety among undergraduate medical students ranges from 25 to 40%, and it has a negative impact on academic achievement and success. However, there is a scarcity of evidence on the prevalence of test anxiety among medical students.4
Medical students are exposed to stress throughout their education. According to reports, 60% of students experience anxiety and despair during their academic careers. Exam anxiety is the most common cause of anxiety. Students with significant test anxiety have been found to do worse academically than those with minimal test anxiety.5
A Quasi Experimental Study to Assess the Effectiveness of Cognitive Behavior Therapy on Test Anxiety Among Students Studying at Selected Nursing Institutes of Punjab (2021-2023).
1. To assess and compare the pre-test and post-test level of test anxiety score among nursing students in experimental and control group.
2. To develop and implement cognitive behavior therapy among nursing students.
3. To determine the effectiveness of cognitive behavior therapy on the level of test anxiety in terms of pre-test and post-test scores comparison between experimental and control group.
4. To find out the association between post-test level of test anxiety in experimental and control group with their selected socio-demographic variables.
The study aims to test the following hypothesis. All the hypotheses will be tested at 0.05 level of significance.
H1: There is significant difference observed in post test scores of test anxiety among nursing students between the experimental group and control group.
H2: There is significant difference observed in pre-test and post-test scores of test anxiety score among nursing students within the experimental group.
· Test anxiety may have impact on student’s health.
· Maladjustments may have impact on student’s health.
· Test anxiety is a measurable phenomenon.
· Test anxiety can be reduced by effective cognitive behavioral therapy interventions.
1. Test Anxiety: It refers to the experience of feeling an intense moment of fear before exams or assessment. This is measured in terms of scores obtained by nursing students on Test Anxiety Questionnaire by Nist and Diehl.
2. Cognitive Behavior Therapy: It refers to the structured therapy that is developed by the researcher for nursing students. It includes 7 sessions that intended to reduce test anxiety such as Cognitive reconstructing / reframing, Relaxation techniques, mindfulness and deep breathing.
REVIEW OF LITERATURE:
Jereyard K.G Maria and Bhuvneshwari U.L. (2020) conducted a study on the level of test anxiety experienced by higher secondary students and effect of psychological intervention in Coimbatore Tamil Nadu. A total of 160 students (92 boys and 68 girls). Nist and Diehl Questionnaire was administered as pretest and posttest. The results showed that 49% of sample experienced moderate anxiety and 51% experienced mild anxiety and 3% experienced severe anxiety. At the end findings revealed that test anxiety was reduced due to intervention.6
Binandeh G. and Koozekonan J Sahebi. (2022) conducted a study on the effect of cognitive behavior therapy on reducing anxiety in high school students in Shabestar city. The study was conducted on 50 female students of 2nd year. Sarason‘s 37 questionnaire was used to collect the data. Pre-test post-test were taken. Alpha test was performed to see the difference in mean for variance analysis. The result showed that the level of confidence was (p<0.005) which was higher and difference (-10.415) with significant (p<0.005) between test anxiety management training group and control group after intervention. Therefore, the null hypothesis is rejected and the research hypothesis is confirmed that cognitive behavioral group training is effective in reducing test anxiety.7
Lethika K and N.V Amudha (2022) conducted a study on the efficacy of cognitive behavior therapy in managing test anxiety and in enhancing achievement motivation among female nursing students in Kozhikode Kerala. The pre test post test design was adopted for 40 student sample. Test anxiety scale developed by Sharma V.P. (2000) were used and 7-day session of CBT were given to the students by using different techniques. The results showed that mean value 60.80 with standard deviation 6.17 after the sessions and showed clear difference in the scores i.e. test anxiety has been reduced among students. The Repeated Measure ANOVA for test anxiety and achievement motivation results revealed that significant differences were observed in all three phases (before, after, and follow-up). Conclusion Cognitive behaviour therapy was found to be effective in reducing test anxiety and enhancing achievement motivation among nursing students.8
MATERIAL AND METHODS:
Target Population: Undergraduate students were the target population for this study.
The Standardized Questionnaire was selected to assess the test anxiety among nursing students. Review of Literature from journals and internet, experts’ opinions and investigators own experiencein the area provided foundation for the construction of tool. A proposed draft was prepared which included - Socio Demographic Profile Sheet with 5 items, Test Profile Sheet with 4 items and Nist and Diehl Questionnaire Scale.
Description of the Tool: Tools consisted of 3 sections given below:
This tool consisted of 5 items such as Age, Course of study, Class, Residence during course of study, Previous Education Board.
This tool consists of 4 items such as utilization of leisure time, self-study hours per day, frequency of test per week, giving test regularly on time.
It is a 5- point Likert Scale with 10 items. Response scale ranges from never to always (1 to 5). Higher scores reflect unhealthy level of test anxiety and low score reflects healthy to keep you focused.
Table 1: Scoring Interpretation of Level of Test Anxiety
|
Level of test anxiety |
Score |
|
Unhealthy level of test anxiety |
36 -50 |
|
Moderate test anxiety |
20 -35 |
|
No test anxiety |
10 – 19 |
|
Maximum score = 50 |
Minimum score = 10 |
The pilot study was carried out as Saraswati Nursing Institute Dhianpura, Kurali Punjab on BSc.(N) 3rd semester on 10 students. Permission was received from concerned authorities. Assurance was given about maintaining confidentiality of the responses given by them. Nist and Diehl Questionnaire were used for assessing test anxiety to collect the data from students.
The study's final data was collected at Saraswati Nursing Institute, Dhianpura and Rayat Bahra College of Nursing, Kharar, Punjab. The investigator acquired written confirmation from the authorities of colleges. The data was collected in the month of March (15th March 2023 to 22th March 2023). A total of 130 subjects by using simple random lottery method 65 in experimental group and 65 in control group were undertaken to conduct a study based on sample selection criteria. The study participants were assured of maintenance of confidentiality and anonymity of the data or information gathered.
On day 1 pre-test was conducted for both the groups and duration of 15-20 minutes by self-reporting technique. After pre–test, Cognitive Behavior Therapy was administered to the experimental group in 7 sessions for 7 days. Each session was for the duration of 60 minutes approximately. No intervention was given to control group. On 8th day, post-test same as of pre- test conducted for both groups to evaluate the effectiveness of Cognitive Behavior Therapy on subjects.
The data were analyzed according to the objectives and hypothesis established for the research study, By Utilizing both descriptive and inferential statistics, the data have been examined.
RESULTS:
|
VARIABLES |
Experimental n =65 F (%) |
Control n=65 F (%) |
chi2 value |
p-value |
|
|
Age (in years) |
18-20 |
30(46%) |
8(12%) |
2.696 |
0.101NS |
|
21-23 |
35(54%) |
57(88%) |
|||
|
Course of the study Class |
B. Sc. Nursing |
65(100%) |
65(100%) |
|
NA |
|
B. Sc Third Year |
27(42%) |
30(46%) |
0.087 |
0.768NS |
|
|
B. Sc Fourth Year |
38(58%) |
34(52%0 |
|||
|
Residence during course of study |
Day Scholar |
11(17%) |
44(68%) |
0.602 |
0.438NS |
|
Hostler |
54(83%) |
21(32%) |
|||
|
Previous education board |
ICSE |
00 |
00 |
5.414 |
0.144NS |
|
CBSE |
11(17%) |
30(46%) |
|||
|
PSEB |
12(18%) |
11(17%) |
|||
|
HPSEB |
23(35%) |
6(9%) |
|||
|
Others |
19(29%) |
18(28%) |
|||
|
Utilization of leisure time |
Self study |
10(15%) |
7(11%) |
2.371 |
0.668NS |
|
Mobile usage |
28(43%) |
33(51%) |
|||
|
Gossiping |
07(11%) |
01(2%) |
|||
|
Playing outdoor games |
11(17%) |
15(23%) |
|||
|
Others |
9(14%) |
9(14%) |
|||
|
Self-study hours per day |
≤1 hour |
10(15%) |
35(54%) |
0.944 |
0.624NS |
|
2-3 hours |
50(77%) |
25(38%) |
|||
|
>3 hours |
05(8%) |
05(8%) |
|||
|
Frequency of test per week |
Once a week |
3(5%) |
18(28%) |
6.208 |
0.045* |
|
Twice a week |
51(78%) |
29(45%) |
|||
|
Twice a week |
11(17%) |
18(28%) |
|||
|
Giving test regularly on scheduled time |
Yes |
47(72%) |
37(57%) |
1.205 |
0.548NS |
|
No |
02(3%) |
08(12%) |
|||
|
Sometimes |
16(25%) |
20(31%) |
|||
*= Significant; NS = non-significant
Table 3: Frequency and Percentage distribution of Pre-test and Post-test of Test Anxiety Scores in Experimental and Control group N=130
|
Test anxiety level (score) |
Experimental group n=65 |
Control groupn=65 |
||
|
Pre test n (%) |
Post test n (%) |
Pre test n (%) |
Post test n (%) |
|
|
Unhealthy level (36-50) |
07(10.8%) |
00 |
06(9.2%) |
06(9.2%) |
|
Moderate level (20-35) |
57(87.7%) |
03(4.6%) |
59(90.8%) |
59(90.8%) |
|
No test anxiety (10-19) |
1(1.5%) |
62(95.4%) |
00 |
00 |
Table 3 and figure 1: depicts that the frequency and percentage distribution of pretest and post level of test anxiety scores among experimental group and control group.
In experimental group pre test scores revealed that 07(10.8%) subjects experienced unhealthy level of test anxiety, 57(87.7%) subjects had moderate level of test anxiety and only 01(1.5%) had no test anxiety. On the other hand post test scores revealed that majority of the subjects 62(95.4%) had no test anxiety and only 03(4.6%) subjects experienced moderate level of test anxiety.
In control group the pre test scores revealed that 06(9.2%) subjects had Unhealthy level of test anxiety, majority 59(90.8%) subjects had moderate level of test anxiety. On the other hand, post test scores revealed majority of the subjects 59(90.8%) had moderate level of test anxiety and only 0 6(9.2%) had unhealthy level of test anxiety.
Figure 1: Frequency and percentage distribution of pre-test and post-test of experimental and control group of Test Anxiety.
Table 4: Comparison between Mean Pre-test and Post-test of Test Anxiety score among students in Experimental and Control group.
N=130
|
|
Test Anxiety Score |
Paired t Test |
||||||
|
Pretest |
Posttest |
|||||||
|
Group |
N |
Mean ± SD |
Mean ± SD |
Mean difference |
df |
t |
Result |
|
|
Experimental Group |
65 |
28.72 ± 5.017 |
15.29 ± 2.441 |
13.43 |
64 |
18.246 |
p value<0.001 Significant |
|
|
Control Group |
65 |
29.76 ± 4.589 |
29.91 ± 4.520 |
-0.15 |
64 |
1.915 |
P value=0.06 NS |
|
|
Unpaired t- test |
Df |
128 |
Df |
128 |
|
|||
|
T |
1.241 |
T |
22.938 |
|||||
|
Result |
p value =0.217NS |
Result |
p value = 0.001 significant |
|||||
Table 5: Association of post test score of test anxiety among students in experimental group with their selected socio-demographic variables N=65
|
Variables |
Test Anxiety Score |
|
||||
|
Below median |
Above median |
df |
Chi2 value |
p Value |
||
|
Age (in years) |
18-20 |
16 |
14 |
1 |
.023 |
.878NS |
|
21-23 |
18 |
17 |
||||
|
Class |
B. Sc Third Year |
14 |
13 |
1 |
.004 |
.951NS |
|
B. Sc Fourth Year |
20 |
18 |
||||
|
Residence during course of study |
Day Scholar |
05 |
06 |
1 |
1.427 |
.490NS |
|
Hostler |
29 |
25 |
||||
|
Previous education board |
CBSE |
08 |
03 |
3 |
2.569 |
.463NS |
|
PSEB |
05 |
07 |
||||
|
HPPSEB |
12 |
11 |
||||
|
Others |
09 |
10 |
||||
|
Utilization of leisure time |
Self study |
07 |
03 |
4 |
5.771 |
.217NS |
|
Mobile usage |
11 |
17 |
||||
|
Gossiping |
03 |
04 |
||||
|
Playing outdoor games |
06 |
05 |
||||
|
Others |
07 |
02 |
||||
|
Self-study hours per day |
≤1 hour |
04 |
06 |
2 |
.783 |
.676NS |
|
2-3 hours |
27 |
23 |
||||
|
>3 hours |
03 |
02 |
||||
|
Frequency of test per week |
Once a week |
02 |
01 |
2 |
1.506 |
.471NS |
|
Twice a week |
28 |
23 |
||||
|
Twice a week |
04 |
07 |
||||
|
Giving test regularly on scheduled time |
Yes |
24 |
23 |
2 |
1.887 |
.389NS |
|
No |
02 |
0 |
||||
|
Sometimes |
08 |
08 |
||||
Table 5: depicts the association of post-test of test anxiety score in experimental group with their selected socio- demographic variables, based on chi square test there was no significant association of test anxiety score with age, class, residence during course of study, previous education board, utilization of leisure time, self –study hours per day, frequency of test per week, giving test regularly on scheduled time (p>0.005).
Table 6: Association of post test score of test anxiety among students in control group with their selected socio-demographic variables
N=65
|
Variables |
Test Anxiety Score |
|
||||
|
Below median |
Above median |
Df |
Chi2 value |
p Value |
||
|
Age (in years) |
18-20 |
03 |
05 |
1 |
.820 |
.371NS |
|
21-23 |
31 |
26 |
||||
|
Class |
B. Sc Third Year |
11 |
20 |
2 |
7.246 |
.027* |
|
B. Sc Fourth Year |
23 |
11 |
||||
|
Residence during course of study |
Day Scholar |
24 |
20 |
1 |
.273 |
.601NS |
|
Hostler |
10 |
11 |
||||
|
Previous education board |
CBSE |
16 |
14 |
3 |
4.277 |
.233NS |
|
PSEB |
03 |
08 |
||||
|
HPPSEB |
03 |
03 |
||||
|
Others |
12 |
16 |
||||
|
Utilization of leisure time |
Self study |
01 |
06 |
4 |
12.879 |
.012* |
|
Mobile usage |
24 |
09 |
||||
|
Gossiping |
0 |
01 |
||||
|
Playing outdoor Games |
06 |
09 |
||||
|
Others |
03 |
06 |
||||
|
Self-study hours per day |
≤1 hour |
19 |
16 |
2 |
.359 |
.836NS |
|
2-3 hours |
12 |
13 |
||||
|
>3 hours |
03 |
02 |
||||
|
Frequency of test per week |
Once a week |
11 |
07 |
2 |
1.954 |
.376NS |
|
Twice a week |
16 |
13 |
||||
|
Twice a week |
03 |
02 |
||||
|
Giving test regularly on scheduled time |
Yes |
18 |
19 |
2 |
.590 |
.745NS |
|
No |
05 |
03 |
||||
|
Sometimes |
11 |
09 |
||||
Table 6: depicts the association of post test score of test anxiety in control group. Based on chi square test, there was a statistically significant association has been found with class and utilization of leisure time whereas age in years, residence during course of study, previous education board, self-study hours per day, frequency of test per week and giving test regularly on scheduled time were not significantly associated i.e. (p<0.05).
CONCLUSION:
It cannot be argued that test anxiety will persist as long as exams are given, however, the issue of test anxiety cannot be disregarded. In light of cognitive restructuring of nursing students, experiencing anxiety before and during test, research to determine effective cognitive behavioral therapy to cope with test anxiety is essential.
As per findings of the present study, Cognitive Behavior Therapy was valuable psychotherapy in reducing test anxiety among nursing students.
Based on obtained results, it is suggested that short term test anxiety reducing strategies like cognitive behavior therapy needs to be incorporated by nursing teachers and psychiatric nurses for test anxiety and student well-being.
DISCUSSION:
Setyowati A, Rayaginamsih F, Fahriza I (2019)33 conducted a study on behavioral cognitive counselling for reducing test anxiety among university students. The post scores highlighted that 60.91% students had low level of test anxiety and 30.09% students possessed moderate anxiety. Result revealed that cognitive counselling was effective to reduce test anxiety among university students.9
The result of study supported by Nikpour G, Kargozar A, Ghribzadeh S (2021)12 significant difference in mean pre and post test scores of experimental group and control groups were 32.73±5.67 and 32.07±5.75 respectively whereas in post-test the mean and standard deviation were 45.53±6.80 and 32.20±5.80 in experimental group and control group respectively.10
A similar study was conducted by Zheng G, Zhang Q, Ran G (2023)45 showed association of test anxiety with variables like academic stress, emotional self-efficacy, preantral expectations.11
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT:
I appreciate contribution of all my teachers, family members and my friends for their continuous moral support and cooperation.
“All may not be mentioned, but none is forgotten from the heart” With heart felt and everlasting gratitude.”
ETHICAL CONSIDERATION:
Ethical clearance was obtained from Institutional Ethical committee and BFUHS, Faridkot. Written permissions were obtained from the principal of Saraswati Nursing Institute, Dhianpura, Roopnagar and Rayat Bahra College of Nursing, Kharar. All participants were informed that their participation in the study is voluntary and they can refuse to participate and can withdraw from the study at any time. Throughout the duration of the research, information's confidentiality and anonymity were upheld.
REFERENCES:
1. Olabisi O. Effects of Problem-Solving Technique on Test Anxiety and Academic Performance among Secondary School Students in Ondo State.IOSR Journal of Research and Method in Education. 2014; 4(4): 20-26.
2. Bendict E.G.Test Anxiety: An Educational Intervention. 2014 August. Available from : content (mtsu.edu).
3. Mohamadi M, Alishahi Z, Soleimani N. A Study on Test Anxiety and its Relationship to Test Score and Self-actualization of Academic EFL Students in Iran. Procedia - Soc. Behav Sci. 2014 May 6; 98: 1156–64.
4. Tsegay L, Shumet S, Damene W, Gebreegziabhier G, Ayano G. Prevalence and determinants of test anxiety among medical students in Addis Ababa Ethiopia. BMC Med Educ. 2019 Nov 14; 19: 423.
5. Patil S, Aithala M. Exam anxiety: Its prevalence and causative factors among Indian medical students. Natl J Physiol Pharm Pharmacol. 2017 Jan 1; 7: 1.
6. Jereyard.K, Bhuvaneshwari.L: Test Anxiety In Higher Secondary Students, Indian Journal of Applied Research. Available from: https://www.worldwidejournals.com/indian-journal-of-applied- research-(IJAR)/article/test-anxiety-in-higher-secondary-students. March 17.2023.
7. Binandeh G, Koozekonan JS. The Effect of Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy on Reducing Anxiety in High School Students. Health Science Journal. 2022.
8. K. Lethika, V.Amudha: efficacy of Cognitive Behavior Therapy in managing test anxiety and in enhancing achievement motivation among female nursing students. International Journal Of Food and Nutritional Sciences. 2022.
9. Setyowati A, Irfan F. study on cognitive behavioral therapy - Google Search[Internet].[cited2023Mar17].Availablefrom: https://www.google.com/search?q=setyowati+aprilia+%2C+irfan+fahi za+study+on+cognitive+behavioral+therapy.
10. G Nikpour, A Kargozar, S Ghribzadeh. The Effectiveness of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) on Students‘ Test Anxiety. Journal of Depression and Anxiety Forecast. 2021; 4: 5.
11. Zheng G, Zhang Q, Ran G. The association between academic stress and test anxiety in college students: The mediating role of regulatory emotional self-efficacy and the moderating role of parental expectations. Front Psychol [Internet]. 2023 [cited 2023 May 13]; 14. Available from: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg. 2023.1008679.
|
Received on 27.03.2026 Revised on 09.05.2026 Accepted on 17.06.2026 Published on 27.07.2026 Available online from August 01, 2026 Asian J. Nursing Education and Research. 2026;16(3):166-172. DOI: 10.52711/2349-2996.2026.00034 ©A and V Publications All right reserved
|
|
|
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License. Creative Commons License. |
|